Commentary · Fraud & asset recovery · Technology disputes

The burn and reissue remedy: should it be the starting point for crypto recovery?

By V Kumar Sharma · August 2025 · 8 min read · First published on LinkedIn as a two-part series

Bitcoin and Ether coins in front of a price chart
Photo by Pierre Borthiry on Unsplash
In short
  • In the burn and reissue (B&R) remedy, the issuer of a token destroys tokens taken from a victim and issues replacements to them: full restitution in a few clicks.
  • No law currently compels issuers to do it. They decide case by case, often to protect their token's price rather than to help victims.
  • The usual objections (decentralisation, cost, misuse) can be answered with clear frameworks and safeguards.
  • It isn't theoretical: regulated US tokenised funds and listed companies already provide it by contract through their transfer agents. We have executed it successfully ourselves.

What the remedy is

A victim loses tokens to a hack, scam or mistake. The issuer that created them then burns those tokens, usually while they sit in a bad actor's wallet, by permanently removing them from circulation, typically by sending them to an irretrievable "burn address". It then reissues equivalent tokens to the victim. One for one, full restitution, with no need for a long chase on and off chain or for costly court proceedings with no certainty of recovery.

If issuers have the tools to undo the harm, shouldn't this be the starting point for making victims whole?

Where things stand

Today no law compels issuers to execute the remedy. It is discussed quietly, case by case. Some issuers burn tokens to protect price and ecosystem, so a bad actor can't dump millions of tokens and crash the market, but keep a discretion over whether to reissue to victims. Without a clear framework, issuers will understandably act in their own interests. The interests of victims should come first.

Three objections, and the answers

1. "It undermines decentralisation"

Critics say an issuer's power to burn tokens in someone else's wallet contradicts the idea of a decentralised asset. The emperor has no clothes: issuers typically already keep control of key smart contract functions, including burning. The real question is what framework should govern that discretion. An issuer can also refer the decision to a DAO vote, which gives weight to decentralised governance.

2. "It is too costly and complex"

Verifying claims, coordinating stakeholders and executing burns and remints takes real technical effort. But with planning, streamlined procedures and automation, the cost is manageable and worth it for a remedy that actually recovers assets.

3. "It will be abused"

False or exaggerated claims could push issuers to interfere with legitimate holdings, leaving them caught between competing stories and exposed to liability. Safeguards answer this: independent verification, court orders, or set evidentiary thresholds before the remedy is used.

It already exists in regulated markets

In US tokenised fund structures, a transfer agent keeps the official register, and the transfer agent agreement typically gives it the power and obligation to execute the remedy:

  • Figure Certificate Company. Its transfer agent agreement, filed with the SEC, provides that for lost tokens the agent burns them and issues replacements once it approves an affidavit of loss and indemnity. For stolen tokens it promptly freezes them and decides, with the fund, whether they were lawfully transferred (clause 3.2).
  • BlackRock's BUIDL, with Securitize as transfer agent. Securitize has told the SEC that erroneous or fraudulent transfers can be corrected by burning tokens and reissuing them to the correct holder.
  • Exodus Movement, a listed crypto-wallet company with tokenised shares. Its 2021 offering circular describes the transfer agent's ability to freeze, revoke and reassign tokens if keys are lost or stolen.

For how this could be built into regulation, see my piece on the proposals made to MAS for enforceable burn, freeze and remint rights.

The limits

The remedy is not a cure-all. There is usually a narrow window, while assets sit in a bad actor's wallet. Open questions remain. Should it be imposed top-down by legislation, or built into existing frameworks, for example as a contractual right to specific performance of the issuer's obligation? And what happens once assets move through a mixer or a decentralised exchange and become a different asset: can the right issuer still act?

From experience

Our team has seen and executed the B&R remedy successfully, outside the Tether/USDT ecosystem, including through a DAO-approved burn and remint. An industry-wide remedy would cut the scale of hack and scam losses by forcing bad actors to move value off-chain into the real world, where conventional recovery tools bite. The blockchain shouldn't be a safe haven for stolen assets.

Frequently asked questions

What is the burn and reissue remedy?
The issuer burns misappropriated tokens and mints equivalent replacements to the victim.
Is an issuer legally required to do it?
Generally not, unless it has agreed to by contract, as some regulated US tokenised funds have.

Lost tokens to a hack or scam? Speed matters. Read the first 72 hours, or get in touch.

General information only, not legal advice.

V Kumar Sharma

V Kumar Sharma is a Partner at Eldan Law LLP and a technology disputes lawyer acting on cyber incident response, fraud and asset recovery, data protection and international arbitration. ALB Asia 40 Under 40 (2026) & Rising Star (2025). Co-Chair, Blockchain Association Singapore Web3 Cybersecurity Sub-Committee.
Get in Touch