Case note · International arbitration · Technology disputes

DJP v DJO [2025] SGCA(I) 2: an arbitral award set aside for copying from earlier awards

By V Kumar Sharma · 20 November 2026 · 7 min read

Library of law books with marble busts
Photo by Giammarco Boscaro on Unsplash
Case
DJP and others v DJO [2025] SGCA(I) 2 (Civil Appeal No 6 of 2024)
Court
Court of Appeal of Singapore, on appeal from the Singapore International Commercial Court ([2024] SGHC(I) 24)
Judges
Sundaresh Menon CJ, Steven Chong JCA and David Edmond Neuberger IJ (judgment delivered by Menon CJ)
Decided
8 April 2025 (heard 23 January 2025)
Judgment
Read on eLitigation
In short
  • Singapore's Court of Appeal upheld the setting aside of an ICC award in which at least 212 of 451 paragraphs were copied from the awards in two parallel arbitrations chaired by the same presiding arbitrator.
  • Copying is not automatically a breach of natural justice. What matters is where the material came from, what kind of material it is, and the surrounding circumstances.
  • Here a fair-minded, informed observer would suspect the tribunal had not brought an open mind to the dispute, and the tribunal relied on material the parties never had a chance to address. Both are breaches of natural justice.
  • The breach permeated the whole award, so it was set aside in full. The court made clear it was not suggesting bad faith.

The facts

The respondent, DJO, is a special purpose vehicle that manages India's Dedicated Freight Corridors. The appellants were a consortium that won a tender for a contract relating to DJO's western Dedicated Freight Corridors and signed a contract (the "CPT-13 Contract") in August 2015, based on the 1999 FIDIC Conditions as amended.

On 19 January 2017 India's Ministry of Labour and Employment issued a notification raising minimum wages. The consortium claimed extra payment for the higher labour costs as a change in legislation under clause 13.7. DJO resisted on grounds including limitation, waiver and the clause 20.1 notice requirement. The contract was governed by Indian law and the dispute went to ICC arbitration seated in Singapore.

The tribunal was made up of three eminent retired Indian judges: a former Chief Justice of India as president, and two former Chief Justices of Indian High Courts as co-arbitrators. The president had also presided over two parallel arbitrations seated in New Delhi, involving DJO and other consortia (with one company in common) under related corridor contracts, on similar wage-notification claims. The two co-arbitrators sat on neither of those tribunals.

The tribunal issued its award on 24 November 2023, largely in the consortium's favour. It was undisputed that at least 212 of its 451 paragraphs had been copied from the two earlier awards. The copied text included a passage dealing with a computation DJO had never put forward in this arbitration, the wording of a version of clause 13.8 taken from one of the other contracts, and references to Indian arbitration legislation on interest and costs, although the seat was Singapore.

The SICC set the award aside under section 24(b) of the International Arbitration Act (breach of natural justice) and did not need to decide DJO's other grounds. The consortium appealed.

The issues

  1. Did the copying give rise to apparent bias: would a fair-minded, informed observer suspect the tribunal had prejudged the dispute?
  2. Did the tribunal deny the parties a fair hearing by relying on material from the parallel arbitrations that they could not address?
  3. If there was a breach, should the award be set aside in whole or only in part?

The decision

1. Apparent bias: the tribunal's mind was not shown to be open

The court applied the familiar objective test: whether a fair-minded, informed observer would reasonably suspect that the tribunal had not approached the matter with an open mind. Bad faith is not the test (at [89]).

The court was careful about copying as such. Copying uncontested and uncontroversial material, such as a statement of the relevant facts, "may" not be objectionable "in and of itself" (at [44]). It is also "not inherently wrong for an arbitrator to resolve two related disputes in the same manner" (at [71]). The source and context of the copied material matter, and the analysis is fact-sensitive.

On these facts, though, the court answered the apparent bias question "plainly in the affirmative" (at [70]): an observer would suspect the president had been materially influenced by the earlier decisions. The tribunal had to consider the dispute afresh, especially as two of its three members had not sat in the parallel arbitrations, there was new counsel on at least one side, and some arguments were new. Instead, large portions of the earlier awards were reproduced without being adjusted for differences in the arguments or the contracts, common issues were all resolved to the same conclusion, and the errors showed the text had not been tailored to the case. An observer might also reasonably apprehend that the tribunal had not grappled with the expanded argument DJO actually made on clause 20.1. The court also discussed the risk of anchoring and confirmation bias when a decision-maker starts from earlier reasoning.

The consortium's answer, that 169 paragraphs had been drafted afresh and the errors were technical, did not help. The court said that paragraph-by-paragraph approach was inapposite: the complaint was that the arbitration "had been decided by means of an unfair process" (at [67]).

2. Fair hearing: material the parties could not address

The parallel awards were confidential to other arbitrations, and the parties had no opportunity in this arbitration to address them. The court treated the content drawn from those awards as extraneous considerations that were never put to the parties. Where a tribunal reaches its decision "by relying on material that the parties have not had access to", that will, subject to materiality and prejudice, presumptively breach the fair hearing rule (at [57]).

The court also stressed equality within the tribunal itself. Each arbitrator "should be equally placed to have the same access to the details of the dispute at hand" (at [60]). A president who brings in knowledge from other arbitrations creates an asymmetry with the co-arbitrators as well as with the parties. There was nothing before the court on whether the co-arbitrators knew the president had drawn on the parallel awards, and the court said nothing turned on this: even assuming they did not know, its analysis was unaffected.

3. Setting aside in full, with no remittal

The consortium argued that, at most, only the tainted parts should go. The court disagreed: "the breach of natural justice permeated the whole Award, and it was correctly set aside in its entirety" (at [87]). Partial setting aside and remittal may suit an isolated breach. Here, because remission is an alternative to setting aside and the setting aside was upheld, it was no longer open to the consortium to seek remission on appeal. The appeal was dismissed. The court added that it did "not insinuate any bad faith on the part of the Tribunal" (at [89]).

Why it matters

  • Process, not outcome. The court did not ask whether the award reached the right answer. It asked whether the process was fair. A "correct" award can still fall.
  • Repeat arbitrators and related disputes. Infrastructure, construction, platform and fintech disputes often come in clusters, with the same employer, operator or exchange facing several claimants. Parties should ask early whether any arbitrator sits on related tribunals and what that means for confidentiality and equal access to material.
  • Information asymmetry is the real risk. Where an arbitrator, or one side, knows the content of related confidential awards and others on the tribunal or in the case do not, the fairness problem exists before a word of the award is written.
  • A warning for templates and drafting tools. This is my own view, not something the court addressed: similar reasoning could apply to an award, judgment or expert report drafted from templates or generated with AI tools. The question is whether the decision-maker engaged with this dispute and these submissions. Unadjusted errors, such as the wrong contract clause or another country's arbitration statute, are exactly what will be used to show they did not.
  • Read the award line by line. In this case the giveaways were concrete: a computation nobody had proposed, a clause from another contract, the wrong statute. The deadline to apply to set aside is short (generally three months from receipt of the award under Article 34(3) of the Model Law), so review a new award promptly.

Arbitration clauses and the way they are run are a recurring theme in technology disputes. See my notes on exchange terms of use and what users really agree to and on the Bitget exploit and vendor liability.

Frequently asked questions

Can an award be set aside in Singapore because the tribunal copied from other awards?
Yes, if the copying shows a breach of natural justice. In DJP v DJO the award was set aside in full because a fair-minded observer would suspect prejudgment and the tribunal relied on material from other arbitrations that the parties had no opportunity to address. Copying is not automatically a breach of natural justice.
Is it wrong for an arbitrator to decide two related disputes the same way?
No. The Court of Appeal said that is not inherently wrong. The problem here was reliance on confidential material from other arbitrations, without giving the parties a chance to address it, and without adapting it to the case argued.
Did the court find bad faith?
No. The test is objective, and the court said bad faith is simply not the test. It expressly said it was not suggesting bad faith on the tribunal's part.

Facing a challenge to, or enforcement of, an arbitral award in a technology or digital asset dispute? Get in touch.

This case note is general information and is not legal advice. It summarises a published judgment; read the full judgment for the court's reasoning.

V Kumar Sharma

V Kumar Sharma is a Partner at Eldan Law LLP and a technology disputes lawyer acting on cyber incident response, fraud and asset recovery, data protection and international arbitration. ALB Asia 40 Under 40 (2026) & Rising Star (2025). Co-Chair, Blockchain Association Singapore Web3 Cybersecurity Sub-Committee.
Get in Touch